What results is the destination producing? What is the demand? What is the supply? What changes are expected? Part One: A stable market for an increasing revenue per room.
At the gateway to the Bavarian Alps, Munich is Germany's third largest city with 1.6 million inhabitants in 2019, and more than 2.3 million including its urban area. Located in southern Bavaria, the city enjoys a privileged location, being close to the Austrian, Swiss and Czech borders.
It is the richest city of the country and its prosperity is partly due to the many companies that have established their headquarters there, especially after the Second World War, when many companies left Berlin or East Germany to settle in the Bavarian capital.
Among the companies present today are the famous German automotive industry leader, the BMW Group, the Siemens Energy Group, banking companies such as Allianz and subsidiaries of multinational companies such as Amazon.de, McDonald's Deutschland, Burger King Deutschland and Yahoo! Deutschland GmbH.
Munich's economy is therefore very much focused on industrial activity, especially the automotive and aerospace industries. It is also known for its activities in the fields of scientific research, biotechnology and finance, as the country's second largest financial centre after Frankfurt.
Being a major business centre, the city is also a popular destination for luxury shopping and the traditional gateway to Bavaria and its castles. Tourism is therefore a key sector of Munich's economy, not least through its famous Oktoberfest beer festival, which takes place from late September to early October and attracts around six million visitors every year.
In 2018, there were 8,265,994 arrivals (national and international), an increase of +6.5% over the previous year (data from the Munich Tourist Office). A total of 17,089,892 overnight stays were made, an increase of +11.9%, i.e. a faster growth than that of arrivals, indicating an increase in tourist stays.
The destination hosts as much for its annual festival as for its cultural (museums, castles, ...), sporting (winter sports in the Alps, nature sports in the hinterland, etc.) and corporate headquarters which attract many business travellers each year. Its high-quality reception infrastructure ensures optimal conditions for the organisation of international events.
Indeed, the city welcomed 93,444 participants in international congresses and meetings in 2018, placing it 4th in the world in the annual ICCA city ranking. In terms of the number of events, the city is nevertheless ranked 35th in the ranking, with a total of 67 international meetings, including two major events that received approximately 30,000 participants.
A successful destination
The number of overnight stays has increased considerably in recent years. They have almost doubled between 2009 and 2018, from 9.9 million to 17.0 million overnight stays. Indeed, overnight stays have increased every year, except for 2016, when a decline in activity was observed.
A decline of -0.2% in earnings was recorded in 2016, largely due to the attack that occurred on 22 July 2016 in a shopping mall in the suburbs of Munich. This shooting, which left around ten people dead and sixteen wounded, affected the destination, as did similar events in Paris and Brussels. As a result, overnight stays fell to 14.02 million in 2016. However, tourism picked up again the following year: +8.9% more overnight stays in 2017.
The year 2018 also marks the period with the second best growth after 2010, i.e. an increase of +11.9% in overnight stays to reach a total of 17.0 million. In 2010, growth was +12.4%, representing a gain of 1.23 million overnight stays.
A predominantly national demand
One of the reasons why demand was only slightly impacted by the 2016 event is to be linked to the market sources. Indeed, tourists are primarily nationals.
German overnight stays accounted for just over half (51%) of all overnight stays in 2018, with a total of 8.75 million overnight stays. This makes it the largest of the issuing markets for the destination. Far behind comes the American market, which accounts for 7% of local demand, for 1.16 million overnight stays.
The other markets are mainly European (UK, Italy, Switzerland, Austria, Spain) or relatively close to Europe (Gulf countries, Russia), with the exception of China, which is in the top 10, and individually represents between 2 and 3% of total overnight stays.
Munich is therefore a destination that is primarily geared towards the German-speaking region, whether for German, Austrian or Swiss markets. With a certain international recognition but still relatively limited influence, the destination relies above all on domestic demand which ensures a certain stability in its performance, as it is less sensitive to major events, as foreign markets can be.
Stable performance for a mature market
Overall, the Munich market has shown relatively stable results over the last seven years. Over the period 2012-2019, occupancy varied slightly. Only the average daily rate increased, mainly due to natural economic inflation, resulting in a slight increase in income per available room over the seven-year period.
As proof of a destination that is both mature and successful, three-quarters of the hotel rooms in the Munich conurbation were occupied in 2018, representing an average annual occupancy rate (OR) of 77.28%. This indicator is on the rise, with a net gain of +0.66 points compared to 2017. However, the first three quarters of 2019 showed a decline in performance, with the occupancy rate down 0.25 points compared with the same period in 2018. Also, the period from 2012 to 2019 was particularly marked by a decline in hotel activity in 2016, following the July 2016 attack.
Unlike Brussels, Munich had some difficulty in returning to the level of performance of 2015. Occupancy experienced the largest decline in the 2012-2019 period, so that the OR of 2019 (77.0%) has not yet reached the result of the year before the attack (77.86%). The difference is only very small, less than one percentage point between 2015 and 2019: only -0.83 points of occupancy.
The "drop" in 2016 corresponds to a -1.5 point drop in occupancy in the Munich supply to an OR of 76.4%. Although the recovery is certainly gradual, with +0.3 pt in 2017 and +0.7 pt in 2018, the occupancy rate nevertheless shows relatively stable results despite the tragic event of 2016. Moreover, the result is up compared to the beginning of the period: +2.88 points more in 2019 than in 2012, when the OR was 74.16%. The growth is therefore real on the scale of the 2012-2019 period.
By way of comparison, the occupancy rate in Brussels lost -10.9 points in the year of the attacks, to regain +9.8 the following year. The variation is therefore very significant, with as many cycles of strong growth as cycles of strong decline. Munich, on the other hand, reveals a rather steady market, fuelled by solid demand that is only slightly sensitive to events.
Regarding rates, the average daily rate (ADR) shows a much greater variation, as mentioned above. Over the whole 2012-2019 period, the annual ADR has increased by +16.8%. It only increased from year to year, except for 2017, where the impact of the 2016 attack was felt, leading to a drop in ADR of -3.6% compared to 2016. However, rates rose again in 2018, at a rate of +5.4%, stabilising at +2.7% during the first three quarters of 2019.
Brussels showed roughly similar losses (-1.8% in 2016) and gains (+5.6% in 2017) in ADR, a rebound that is roughly equivalent in Amsterdam (+6.0%), Paris (+8.5%), and even higher to London (+1.5%).
The average monthly rate in Munich thus reaches €109.26 excluding VAT in November 2019, compared with €101.63 excluding VAT for the same period in 2012. However, its highest level is nevertheless reached in September 2018 (€161.65 excluding VAT).
In terms of revenue per available room (RevPAR), the fluctuation is just as great as that of the average rate. While the ADR earns €17.32 excluding VAT between 2012 and 2019, the RevPAR earns €16.31 excluding VAT, a result slightly below the evolution of the ADR due to a fairly stable occupancy which has slightly "slowed" the evolution of the RevPAR over the period.
It reaches an annual average of €92.90 excluding VAT in 2019, slightly above the level of 2018 (€90.76 excluding VAT, i.e. an increase of +2.4% between 2018 and 2019), which is significantly higher than that of 2017 (€85.42 excluding VAT, i.e. an increase of +6.3% between 2017 and 2018). In 2017, RevPAR fell by -3.2%, from €88.25 excluding VAT in 2016 to €85.42 excluding VAT in 2017.
This fall is well below the decline in the Brussels market during the post-attack period in 2016 (-16.6%) - although the indicator recovered just as quickly in 2017 (+18.2%) and even in 2018 (+12.1%).
Seasonality marked only by rates
Munich is a market with demand that is both stable from one year to the next and throughout the year. Indeed, the intra-annual variation in hotel occupancy is only very small. Some periods of the year show slightly better results than others, but overall, occupancy varies only slightly each month compared to the annual average.
Only the average rate indicates a certain "seasonality" of the destination. Hoteliers tend to drive rates up in April, when seminar and event activity is particularly intense (bauma in April 2013, 2016 and 2019 - the world's largest construction trade fair held every three years, see the "Business tourism" section for more details) and in September and October, the Oktoberfest period.
This article was published over a month ago, and is now only available to our Premium & Club members
Access all content and enjoy the benefits of subscription membership
and access the archives for more than a month following the articleRegister
Already signed up? Identify yourself
An articleBuy the article
A pack of 10 articlesBuy the pack
Already signed up? Already signed up? Already signed up? Already registered? Login here!